Published June 17, 2026 · 40 years in trucking & the trades
What we cover in Carthage
Pick a coverage to quote or buy — or book a consult and we'll sort it out together.
Why folks in Carthage choose a local agent
When you're in Carthage, Smith County, you get a real person who knows TN — not a 1-800 menu. Billy E. Whited is a licensed local agent shopping 80+ carriers to fit your home, vehicle, farm, or business, and can quote, bind, or sit down with you in person, over Zoom, or on the phone.
Nearby towns we also cover:
Insurance in Carthage: the local picture
Living and working in Carthage, you know our town has its own unique insurance needs. For our businesses, like Bonnell Aluminum, commercial property and general liability are critical to protect their operations and assets, especially with manufacturing risks. Riverview Regional Medical Center needs robust professional liability alongside property and workers' comp. And for all our local businesses, from Busy Bee Plumbing to McCall Farms Excavation, having solid general liability, commercial auto, and even tools and equipment coverage is just plain smart. Tractor Supply Company also has significant commercial property and liability exposures common to retail.
Our homes here tell a story, with many older, historic properties like the Cullum Mansion and others from the early 1900s. That means replacement costs can be higher due to specialized materials and craftsmanship, so homeowners need to make sure their dwelling coverage is adequate, maybe even looking at guaranteed replacement cost or extended dwelling coverage. While asphalt roofs are common, they're constantly tested by our Middle Tennessee weather.
Speaking of weather, we're no strangers to severe storms. Carthage gets its share of hail – with 58 detected events – plus we're in a region prone to severe thunderstorms and tornadoes. This makes comprehensive homeowners and commercial property policies absolutely essential for wind and hail damage. And with the Cumberland River right here, flood insurance isn't just a recommendation; it's a necessity for many properties, as standard policies don't cover flood damage. Understanding your FEMA flood zone is key to protecting your biggest investment.
Population: 2291 (2020)
Housing in Carthage
Carthage, TN, features a housing stock that includes older, historic properties, such as the 1848 Cullum Mansion (https://www.priceypads.com/historic-1848-cullum-mansion-reduced-to-1m-in-carthage-tennessee/) and other homes built in the early 1900s (https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/97-McClures-Bend-Ln-Carthage-TN-37030/81224490_zpid/). While specific proportions of brick, frame, or manufactured homes are not detailed, the presence of historic structures suggests traditional construction. Asphalt roofs are common (https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/97-McClures-Bend-Ln-Carthage-TN-37030/81224490_zpid/). The existence of historic properties implies that replacement costs for older homes could be higher due to specialized materials and craftsmanship. New subdivisions are not explicitly identified, suggesting the older housing stock is a significant characteristic.
Major local employers & who's hiring
- Bonnell Aluminum — Manufacturing Actively hiring
- Riverview Regional Medical Center — Healthcare Actively hiring
- Smith County School District — Education Actively hiring
- Tractor Supply Company — Retail Actively hiring
- McCall DT and Sons Warehouse — warehouse
Local Carthage businesses
A few businesses that call Carthage home — independent of our agency.
- Busy Bee Plumbing, Heating & Air Conditioning — Plumbing, HVAC
- Key and Sons HVAC — HVAC
- D&D Enterprises — Electrical Contractor, Plumbing, General Contractor
- Integrity Tree Service — Tree Trimming
- Adam Nash Enterprise Inc. — Septic, Excavation
- McCall Farms Excavation — Excavation
- Terry Lefever TLT Excavating — Excavation
- Tractor Supply — Local Shops
- Teresa's Gifts — Local Shops
- Mid-Tenn Terrazzo & Tile — Other Contractors
- Caney Fork Farms — Farms
- Citgo — c-store
Local landmarks & geography
- Cumberland River — Major waterway that defines the local geography; properties adjacent to the river are susceptible to flood risk, impacting flood insurance requirements and premiums. General flood hazard information is available from FEMA.
- Historic Smith County Courthouse / Downtown Carthage — The historic downtown area, centered around the courthouse, contains older structures. These properties may have higher replacement costs due to unique architectural styles, specialized building materials, and potential preservation requirements, affecting property insurance coverage and value.
- Bonnell Aluminum Plant — A significant industrial employer in Carthage. Large industrial facilities contribute to the local economy, which can indirectly support property values. Depending on the industry, there could be perceived environmental or operational risks in the vicinity.
- Interstate 40 (I-40) — A major interstate highway located south of Carthage, providing significant transportation access. Proximity to major transportation arteries can influence property values due to accessibility and may be a factor in noise or traffic-related considerations.
- Burgess Falls State Park — A prominent state park located near Carthage, TN. While not directly in town, its presence as a natural attraction can contribute to the region's appeal and potentially influence property values in surrounding areas. Proximity to natural areas can sometimes be a factor in wildfire risk assessment, though less prominent in this specific location.
Local facts that shape your coverage
- Doppler radar has detected hail at or near Carthage, TN, on 58 occasions, including 3 occasions during the past year. — Direct severe weather hazard for the town.
- Flooding in Smith County, where Carthage is located, can disrupt access to utilities, emergency services, and transportation, potentially impacting the overall economic well-being of the area. — Highlights the broad impact of flood events on the community.
- Carthage, TN, is situated on the Cumberland River. — Geographical feature significantly contributing to the town's flood risk.
- Properties in Tennessee, including Carthage, are subject to FEMA flood zone designations which determine flood insurance requirements and risk levels. — Indicates the presence of identified flood hazard areas and regulatory requirements.
- As of the most recent census data, the population of Carthage town, Tennessee is 2,327. — Population data provides context for the size of the insurance market and community.
- The median home value in Carthage, TN is $239,600. — Median home value helps inform average dwelling coverage needs and potential replacement costs for homeowners' insurance.
Local figures compiled from public sources: data.census.gov · interactivehailmaps.com · firststreet.org · en.wikipedia.org · fludzone.com · niche.com. Estimates — verify current details with the original source.
Insurance requirements in Tennessee
Tennessee is an at-fault state requiring liability coverage for every driver. Parts of Tennessee face severe storms and flooding, so it's worth reviewing whether flood and adequate wind coverage fit your situation. We compare Tennessee-admitted carriers to match the state's requirements to the coverage you actually need. Verify current state minimums with the Tennessee Department of Commerce & Insurance.
Carthage, TN insurance — common questions
How much does insurance cost in Carthage, TN?
Rates in Carthage and Smith County depend on your home, vehicles, business, and the coverage you choose. As an independent agency we shop 80+ carriers to find your best price — start a quote or call 573-594-5148 for a real number.
Do you write insurance in Carthage?
Yes. InsureToday24 (BNW Services LLC) is a licensed local agency serving Carthage and all of TN — home, auto, farm, business, life, and more.
Can I get a quote in Carthage today?
Absolutely. You can buy simple lines online in minutes, or book a quick consult — in person, over Zoom, or by phone — and we'll get you covered fast.